You are here

Synopsis of the History of Rape and Sodomy

17 February, 2016 - 11:05

The word rape has its roots in the Latin word rapere, which means to steal or seize. At early common law, rape was a capital offense. The elements of rape were forcible sexual intercourse, by a man, with a woman not the spouse of the perpetrator, conducted without consent, or with consent obtained by force or threat of force.  1 The rape prosecution required evidence of the defendant’s use of force, extreme resistance by the victim, and evidence that corroborated the rape victim’s testimony. The common law also recognized the crime of sodomy. In general, sodomy was the penetration of the male anus by a man. Sodomy was condemned and criminalized even with consent because of religious beliefs deeming it a crime against nature. 2

In the 1970s, many changes were made to rape statutes, updating the antiquated common-law approach and increasing the chances of conviction. The most prominent changes were eliminating the marital rape exemption and the requirement of evidence to corroborate the rape victim’s testimony, creating rape shield laws to protect the victim, and relaxing the necessity for the defendant’s use of force or resistance by the victim. 3 Many jurisdictions also changed the name of rape to sexual battery, sexual assault, or unlawful sexual conduct and combined sexual offenses like rape, sodomy, and oral copulation into one statute. Although some states still have statutes that provide the death penalty for rape, the US Supreme Court has held that rape, even child rape, cannot be considered a capital offense without violating theEighth Amendment cruel and unusual punishment clause, rendering these statutes unenforceable. 4

Sodomy law has likewise been updated to make sodomy a gender-neutral offense and preclude the criminalization of consensual sexual conduct between adults. The US Supreme Court has definitively held that consensual sex between adults may be protected by a right of privacy and cannot be criminalized without a sufficient government interest. 5

Crime

Criminal Act

Lackof Victim

Consent?

Victim Resistance?

Other Differences

Table 10.1 Comparing Common Law Rape and Sodomy with Modern Statutes

Common- law rape

Penis-vagina penetration

Yes

Yes, extreme resistance

Corroborative evidence required; no spousal rape; capital crime

Modern rape

Some states include any sexual penetration

Yes

Not if force is used, or threat of force that would deter a reasonable person from resisting (See section 10.1.2.2.2.)

No corroborative evidence required; spousal rape is a crime in some jurisdictions; rape is not a capital crime.

Common- law sodomy

Male penis- male anus penetration

No. Even consensual sodomy was criminal.

No. Even consensual sodomy was criminal.

 

Modern sodomy

Gender-neutral penis-anus penetration

Yes

Same as modern rape, above

Consensual sodomy in prison or jail is still criminal in some jurisdictions. (See section 10.1.7.)