You are here

The role of cost structures

15 February, 2016 - 09:58

A critical determinant of market structure is the way in which demand and cost interact to determine the likely number of market participants in a given sector or market. Structure also evolves over the long run: Time is required for entry and exit.

Figure 11.1 shows the demand curve D for the output of an industry in the long run. Suppose, initially, that all firms and potential entrants face the long-run average cost curveLATC_1. At the price P_1, free entry and exit means that each firm produces q1. With the demand curve D, industry output is Q_1. The number of firms in the industry is N_1 (=Q_{1}/q_{1}). If q1, the minimum average cost output on LATC_1, is small relative to D, then N_1 is large. This outcome might be perfect competition – N virtually infinite – or monopolistic competition – N large with slightly differentiated products produced by each firm.

media/image1.png
Figure 11.1 Demand, costs and market structure

With a cost structure defined by LATC_1 this market has space for many firms – perfect or monopolistic competition, each producing approximately q1. If costs correspond toLATC_2, where scale economies are substantial, there may be space for just one producer. The intermediate case, LATC_3, can give rise to oligopoly, with each firm producing more than q1 but less than a monopolist. These curves encounter their MES at very different output levels.

Instead, suppose that the production structure in the industry is such that the long-run average cost curve is LATC_2. Here, scale economies are vast, relative to the market size. At the lowest point on this cost curve, output is large relative to the demand curve D. If this one firm were to act like a monopolist it would produce an output where MR = MC in the long run and set a price such that the chosen output is sold. Given the scale economies, there may be no scope for another firm to enter this market, because such a firm would have to produce a very high output to compete with the existing producer. This situation is what we previously called a “natural” monopolist.

Finally, the cost structure might involve curves of the type LATC_3, which would give rise to the possibility of several producers, rather than one or very many. This results in oligopoly.

It is clear that one crucial determinant of market structure is minimum efficient scale relative to the size of the total market as shown by the demand curve. The larger the minimum efficient scale relative to market size, the smaller is the number of producers in the industry.